Public Forum

Welcome to your Public Forum! Please use it to tell all of us what birds you are seeing in your yard, your neighborhood, on your balcony or fire escape, or in your favorite park. Tell us about any wildlife refuges you are visiting. And the birds you are seeing – what are they doing? Are they singing, nest-building, flying, foraging, sitting still and resting? Are they interacting with those of their own species or with others? Are they by themselves? In a flock? Ask questions and learn more about topics that are important to you. And remember, no question is too basic or simple – we all have to start somewhere.

Need help? Click here to Get Started.

Forum Navigation
Please or Register to create posts and topics.

Rose-breasted Grosbeaks

A first-year male Rose-breasted Grosbeak has been visiting our feeders for the past few days.  This is by far the latest we have ever seen one.  Probably a migrant?

Carol,

First of all, how wonderful to see a Rose-breasted Grosbeak!  And I think you are correct - this bird is migrating.  I did just look at their range map and they winter in Central and Northern South America.

One of the things I think we all have noticed is that winds have changed over the last 20 years.  And those of us who are older, we can see much change in wind and weather since we were children.  From my point of view, winds are stronger and more sustained.  And storms are more fierce.  And this does affect birds - particularly in spring and fall when they are either migrating or simply moving around.  One of the theories as to why House Sparrows and European Starlings have exploded in population is that while these birds do move around, they do not migrate.  Migration is dangerous for all birds - particularly for younger birds.  I am so glad this grosbeak has found a haven in your yard and at your feeders for some probably much needed rest.  Is it still there?

Are any of the rest of you seeing migrants in your yard, at your feeders, or wherever you are birding right now?  For those of us living east of the Mississippi, Hurricane Helene could have blown birds just about everywhere.  Birds are like us and hunker down during storms, but when flying before and after storms, they can get caught in streams and end up in faraway places.

Linda

Merlin reported that the Rose-breasted Grosbeak was still around yesterday, but we didn't see him.  We did, however, see a very late Eastern Phoebe.

RE: grosbeaks........  I had a group of both male and females come through my yard - it was two weeks ago, so I believe that it was the 24th.

I saw 3 or 4 males and probably 3/4 females.  I watched for awhile, but in less than an hour, they were gone.... so, obviously travelers (and I had not seen any others at my feeders since we moved here in early July).   Barry